Understanding the Difference Between an Employee and a Contractor

As you begin building a new learning environment, one of the things you’ll need to figure out, as your business grows, is who will help support you in bringing your vision to life. Will they be employees or contractors? While both options can play a vital role in your organization’s success, understanding the differences between them can help you make the right decision for your growing team. Let’s break it down in simple terms.  

What Is an Employee?  

Think of an employee as someone who works directly for your organization, under your guidance, on an ongoing basis. You, as the employer, have significant control over their work—like when, where, and how they do it. This kind of structured environment is common in traditional workplaces where everyone follows a set schedule and company rules.  

Employees usually enjoy a variety of benefits that come with their job. These might include health insurance, paid time off, and even retirement plans. The relationship is pretty stable, with employees receiving a steady paycheck (often through wages or salary), which has taxes like Social Security and Medicare that you as the employer deduct from the wages and pay the appropriate government agencies.  

Key Characteristics of an Employee 

- Works under your supervision and control 

- Has set work hours and tasks given to them by the Employer  

- Receives regular pay with taxes deducted by Employer 

- Eligible for company benefits like health insurance and retirement plans 

- Protected by labor laws (e.g., overtime pay, minimum wage, and workplace safety)  

So, if you want someone to be a long-term part of your team, and you plan to oversee their work closely, hiring them as an employee is probably the best option.  

What Is a Contractor?  

On the flip side, a contractor, sometimes called an independent contractor, is hired to complete a specific job or project. They’re experts in their field and bring their specialized skills to the table, but they have a lot more freedom in how they do the work. Contractors manage their own schedules, decide on their work methods, and often juggle multiple clients at once.  

Since contractors are considered self-employed, they don’t receive benefits like health insurance or paid time off from you. They handle their own taxes and typically charge by the project or on an hourly basis. While they might come with a higher price tag, you’re not responsible for all the extra costs, such as payroll taxes and insurance benefits, that come with having a full-time employee.  

Key Characteristics of a Contractor 

- Hired for a specific project, tasks, or area of expertise 

- Works independently, with control over their schedule and methods and the Employer has no legal right to interfere with how they manage their schedule or complete their work 

- No taxes withheld from their pay—they handle their own 

- Doesn’t receive company benefits 

- Can work for multiple clients at once  

If you need someone for specialized work or someone who you do not need to control their schedule, and do not want the commitment of hiring a full-time team member, going with a contractor can make sense.  

Why Does the Distinction Matter?  

Choosing between employees and contractors isn’t just about how much control you want to have over their work. There are also important legal and financial differences that can impact both your organization and the people you hire.  

Here are some key areas where the difference matters:  

1. Control 

   - Employees: You set their schedule, direct their work, and provide training. 

   - Contractors: They decide how, when, and where to work, with more focus on the final result.  

 2. Payment and Taxes 

   - Employees: You withhold taxes (like Social Security and Medicare) from their paychecks, and you also contribute a portion. 

   - Contractors: You pay them the agreed amount, but they handle their own taxes on the income they receive from you  

3. Benefits 

   - Employees: Usually get perks like health insurance, retirement plans, paid leave, etc. 

   - Contractors: No benefits—they manage their own insurance and retirement savings.  

 4. Legal Protections  

   - Employees: Covered by labor laws (such as minimum wage, overtime pay, and protection from wrongful termination). 

   - Contractors: Have less legal protection and are often responsible for their own liability.  

Check Local Laws  

Before finalizing whether someone will be an employee or a contractor, it’s important to consult with a local employment attorney in your state. State laws can vary, and certain factors—like how much control you have over someone’s work or how they’re compensated—can affect how staff members are legally classified. A legal expert can help you avoid misclassification issues and ensure you’re in compliance with all relevant regulations.  

The Bottom Line for Educational Entrepreneurs  

Understanding the differences between employees and contractors, along with consulting with a local employment attorney, will help you make informed decisions and ensure your organization complies with legal and tax obligations.  

Now that you’ve got the basics, you’re ready to start building a team that fits your needs and supports your vision! Here is a table to summarize the information in the article and help you to easily see the differences between an employee v. contractor: 

Ready to learn more? Join the ERC here.